top of page

Robots - 2 legs or wheels. Which is better?

When we think of robots, we might imagine a humanoid figure, walking on two legs like a human. However, in reality, there are many different types of robots, each with their unique design and capabilities. Two of the most common types of robots are those with two legs and those with wheels. In this blog post, we will explore the differences between these two types of robots and the challenges and advantages of each.

Two-Legged Robotics Devices Two-legged robots, also known as bipedal robots, are designed to walk on two legs, much like humans do. These robots are often designed to look humanoid, with a head, torso, and two legs. Two-legged robots have the potential to be very versatile, as they can navigate over uneven terrain and climb stairs, making them useful in many different applications, including search and rescue missions, space exploration, and even military operations. One of the biggest challenges in designing two-legged robots is achieving stability. Unlike wheeled robots, which can easily balance on a stable base, two-legged robots must constantly maintain their balance, which can be difficult, especially on uneven terrain. Additionally, two-legged robots are more prone to tipping over, which can be dangerous in certain situations.

One example of a two-legged robot is Atlas, a humanoid robot developed by Boston Dynamics. Atlas is designed to perform a variety of tasks, including search and rescue operations and disaster response. Atlas is equipped with a range of sensors and cameras, which allow it to navigate its environment and perform complex tasks. However, despite its advanced capabilities, Atlas is still prone to falling over, especially when navigating difficult terrain.

Another example of a two-legged robot is ASIMO, a robot developed by Honda. ASIMO is designed to look and move like a human, with a head, torso, arms, and legs. ASIMO can walk, run, and even climb stairs, making it a versatile robot. However, ASIMO is also very expensive and complex, which limits its practical applications.

Other notable examples of 2 legged robots:

1. Spot - Spot is a four-legged robot developed by Boston Dynamics. It can navigate through uneven terrain, climb stairs and perform various tasks, such as carrying loads and inspecting sites. Spot has been used in applications such as surveying, construction, and public safety. 2. PETMAN - PETMAN is a humanoid robot developed by Boston Dynamics for the U.S. Army. PETMAN is designed to test protective clothing for soldiers and can simulate human movements such as walking, running, and crouching. 3. HUBO - HUBO is a humanoid robot developed by the Korean Advanced Institute of Science and Technology (KAIST). HUBO can walk, run, and climb stairs and is equipped with a range of sensors and cameras for navigation and control. HUBO has been used in applications such as firefighting and disaster response. 4. Valkyrie - Valkyrie is a humanoid robot developed by NASA. It is designed to perform tasks such as maintenance, inspection, and repair on the International Space Station. Valkyrie has two legs and two arms and is equipped with a range of sensors and cameras for navigation and control.

Advantages of Robots with Wheels While two-legged robots are impressive in their own right, robots with wheels also have many advantages. Wheeled robots are typically more stable and easier to control than two-legged robots, making them useful in a variety of applications, including manufacturing, logistics, and transportation.

One of the biggest advantages of wheeled robots is their stability. Wheeled robots are designed to maintain their balance on a stable base, which makes them less prone to tipping over than two-legged robots. Additionally, wheeled robots are typically faster and more efficient than two-legged robots, as they can move quickly and easily over smooth surfaces. One example of a wheeled robot is the Roomba, a robot vacuum cleaner developed by iRobot. The Roomba is designed to navigate and clean floors autonomously, using a range of sensors and cameras to detect obstacles and navigate around them. The Roomba is an excellent example of a wheeled robot that is designed for practical applications, as it is affordable, easy to use, and highly effective at its task.

Another example of a wheeled robot is the Mars rover, a series of robots developed by NASA to explore the surface of Mars. The Mars rover is equipped with six wheels and a range of scientific instruments, which allow it to collect data and perform experiments on the surface of Mars. The Mars rover is an excellent example of a wheeled robot that is designed for exploration and research, as it can navigate over rough terrain and collect valuable scientific data.

Advantages of 2 Legged Robots

1. Versatility: Two-legged robots are capable of navigating through uneven terrain and tight spaces, which makes them ideal for search and rescue operations. In comparison, wheeled robots would struggle to move around in these conditions. 2. Humanoid Interaction: Two-legged robots can be designed to mimic human movement and actions, making them ideal for situations where they need to interact with humans or perform tasks that require a human-like touch. 3. Climbing: Two-legged robots can climb stairs, ladders, and other vertical structures, which can be a significant advantage in certain scenarios. 4. Aesthetically Pleasing: Humans find two-legged robots aesthetically pleasing and relatable, which can be beneficial for some applications, such as in entertainment or marketing.

Disadvantages of 2 Legged Robots

1. Complexity: Designing and building two-legged robots is a complex process, requiring a lot of engineering expertise and resources. This makes them more expensive and less accessible than other types of robots. 2. Stability: Two-legged robots require advanced algorithms and sensors to maintain their balance, which makes them more prone to tipping over than wheeled robots. This instability can be a significant drawback in situations where the robot is required to carry out precise movements. 3. Power Consumption: Two-legged robots require a significant amount of energy to maintain their balance and perform complex movements. This makes them less energy-efficient than wheeled robots, which can be a disadvantage in applications where power supply is limited. 4. Limited Load Capacity: Two-legged robots have limited load capacity compared to wheeled robots, which can limit their applications in situations where heavy lifting is required.

Conclusion In conclusion, two-legged robots and robots with wheels each have their own unique advantages and challenges. Two-legged robots are versatile and can navigate over uneven terrain, but are more prone to tipping over and can be challenging to control. Robots with wheels are stable and efficient, but may not be as versatile as two-legged robots.

As you probably noted, our team decided that the first version of Gary will be a wheeled one. Do you agree?

bottom of page